{"schema_version":"alpha-governance-record-v2","alpha_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce","ontology_version":"alpha-governance-ontology-v1","as_of":"2026-10-19T23:24:06.212551+00:00","published_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","section":"relationships","data":{"state":"PUBLISHED","relationships":[{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:seat_on:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:5:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"seat_on","from_id":"alpha:person:gina-a-norris-vhi","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Gina A. Norris","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2023-01-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:5","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:seat_on:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:6:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"seat_on","from_id":"alpha:person:loretta-j-feehan-vhi","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Loretta J. Feehan","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2014-01-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:6","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:seat_on:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:7:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"seat_on","from_id":"alpha:person:mary-a-tidlund-vhi","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Mary A. Tidlund","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2016-01-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:7","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:seat_on:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:8:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"seat_on","from_id":"alpha:person:michael-s-simmons","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Michael S. Simmons","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2022-01-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:8","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:seat_on:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:9:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"seat_on","from_id":"alpha:person:terri-l-herrington-vhi","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Terri L. Herrington","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2018-01-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:9","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:seat_on:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:10:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"seat_on","from_id":"alpha:person:thomas-e-barry-vhi","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Thomas E. Barry","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2000-01-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:10","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:seat_on:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:11:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"seat_on","from_id":"alpha:person:w-hayden-mcilroy-vhi","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"W. Hayden McIlroy","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2003-01-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:11","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:12:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:amy-allbach-samford","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Amy Allbach Samford","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:12","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:c74062ddb7d336f2c41ca00825a0ab87d07ddbe5205b64e270f2062994260d11"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:13:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:andrew-b-nace","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Andrew B. Nace","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:13","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:9e14fccee8b3ea42c566650d6d1fcc28f3ff70bdb888eba2840af0a82ff882de"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:14:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:bart-w-reichert","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Bart W. Reichert","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:14","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:a7444fd9db9c37a109511f14bb33d682f5fd0e208d7b1115b91c3036b181e715"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:15:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:bryan-a-hanley","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Bryan A. Hanley","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:15","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:06065325ba53f45113611cf5857af2293fab41f32461df2f355cec98d5661277"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:16:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:d-gregory-scott","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Darci B. Scott","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:16","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:201350d719a3bbee0189836c6db54ae548748c8bc0304f5263231c7e77b53b97"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:17:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:edward-r-moore","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Edward R. Moore","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:17","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:95923758dc801c113feff850aaf060082da957e50f03e59e4e12d5fcceba0124"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:18:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:erica-a-austin","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Erica A. Austin","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:18","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:1cc40753a07df0d340146b6a31866b2b6436ee5715f768d3aa4beff3d10c7c82"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:19:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:jane-r-grimm","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Jane R. Grimm","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:19","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:75cb3bb815dcb881a2db52a4abae50a94ebebc6f4b8ec81e8d511c4e4590a107"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:20:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:john-a-sunny","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"John A. Sunny","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:20","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:f90faf3921477ad9d5d59decc6be70a296bd9d58922955a1e827a2c9fa7ec8ee"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:21:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:kristin-b-mccoy","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Kristin B. McCoy","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:21","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:e693815412a540221e8720f5bc68101ab32a65fe996d46a8a1aff85511e35a50"]},{"relationship_id":"alpha:relationship:executive_of:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:22:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","relationship_type":"executive_of","from_id":"alpha:person:michael-s-simmons","to_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","from_label":"Michael S. Simmons","to_label":"VALHI INC","valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"lifecycle_state":"active","claim_id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:22","evidence_ids":["alpha:projection-evidence:document:9fc073d121e7162bca753d4d8c5a0cc5d147538561f518d01914915832bbef7b"]}]},"claims":[{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:5","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasBoardOrCommitteeRole","object_id":"alpha:person:gina-a-norris-vhi","object_label":"Gina A. Norris","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Gina A. Norris: Director","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"board_seat","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:gina-a-norris-vhi","name":"Gina A. Norris"},"title":"Director","role_category":"director","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2023-01-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2023-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":"DEF 14A vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-09-02T02:01:36.766922+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2023-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:6","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasBoardOrCommitteeRole","object_id":"alpha:person:loretta-j-feehan-vhi","object_label":"Loretta J. Feehan","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Loretta J. Feehan: Director","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"board_seat","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:loretta-j-feehan-vhi","name":"Loretta J. Feehan"},"title":"Director","role_category":"director","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2014-01-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2014-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":"DEF 14A vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-09-02T02:01:36.766922+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2014-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:7","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasBoardOrCommitteeRole","object_id":"alpha:person:mary-a-tidlund-vhi","object_label":"Mary A. Tidlund","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Mary A. Tidlund: Director","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"board_seat","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:mary-a-tidlund-vhi","name":"Mary A. Tidlund"},"title":"Director","role_category":"director","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2016-01-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2016-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":"DEF 14A vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-09-02T02:01:36.766922+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2016-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:8","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasBoardOrCommitteeRole","object_id":"alpha:person:michael-s-simmons","object_label":"Michael S. Simmons","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Michael S. Simmons: Director","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"board_seat","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:michael-s-simmons","name":"Michael S. Simmons"},"title":"Director","role_category":"director","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2022-01-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2022-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":"DEF 14A vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-09-02T02:01:36.766922+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2022-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:9","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasBoardOrCommitteeRole","object_id":"alpha:person:terri-l-herrington-vhi","object_label":"Terri L. Herrington","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Terri L. Herrington: Director","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"board_seat","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:terri-l-herrington-vhi","name":"Terri L. Herrington"},"title":"Director","role_category":"director","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2018-01-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2018-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":"DEF 14A vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-09-02T02:01:36.766922+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2018-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:10","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasBoardOrCommitteeRole","object_id":"alpha:person:thomas-e-barry-vhi","object_label":"Thomas E. Barry","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Thomas E. Barry: Director","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"board_seat","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:thomas-e-barry-vhi","name":"Thomas E. Barry"},"title":"Director","role_category":"director","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2000-01-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2000-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":"DEF 14A vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-09-02T02:01:36.766922+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2000-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:11","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasBoardOrCommitteeRole","object_id":"alpha:person:w-hayden-mcilroy-vhi","object_label":"W. Hayden McIlroy","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"W. Hayden McIlroy: Director","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"board_seat","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:w-hayden-mcilroy-vhi","name":"W. Hayden McIlroy"},"title":"Director","role_category":"director","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2003-01-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2003-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":"DEF 14A vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-09-02T02:01:36.766922+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2003-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:12","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:amy-allbach-samford","object_label":"Amy Allbach Samford","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Amy Allbach Samford: Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:amy-allbach-samford","name":"Amy Allbach Samford"},"title":"Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c74062ddb7d336f2c41ca00825a0ab87d07ddbe5205b64e270f2062994260d11","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:05.684214+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:13","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:andrew-b-nace","object_label":"Andrew B. Nace","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Andrew B. Nace: Executive Vice President and General Counsel","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:andrew-b-nace","name":"Andrew B. Nace"},"title":"Executive Vice President and General Counsel","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:9e14fccee8b3ea42c566650d6d1fcc28f3ff70bdb888eba2840af0a82ff882de","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:05.192448+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:14","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:bart-w-reichert","object_label":"Bart W. Reichert","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Bart W. Reichert: Vice President, Internal Audit","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:bart-w-reichert","name":"Bart W. Reichert"},"title":"Vice President, Internal Audit","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:a7444fd9db9c37a109511f14bb33d682f5fd0e208d7b1115b91c3036b181e715","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:08.683262+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:15","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:bryan-a-hanley","object_label":"Bryan A. Hanley","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Bryan A. Hanley: Senior Vice President and Treasurer","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:bryan-a-hanley","name":"Bryan A. Hanley"},"title":"Senior Vice President and Treasurer","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:06065325ba53f45113611cf5857af2293fab41f32461df2f355cec98d5661277","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:07.160163+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:16","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:d-gregory-scott","object_label":"Darci B. Scott","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Darci B. Scott: Vice President, Tax","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:d-gregory-scott","name":"Darci B. Scott"},"title":"Vice President, Tax","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:201350d719a3bbee0189836c6db54ae548748c8bc0304f5263231c7e77b53b97","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:09.120039+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:17","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:edward-r-moore","object_label":"Edward R. Moore","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Edward R. Moore: Vice President and Controller","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:edward-r-moore","name":"Edward R. Moore"},"title":"Vice President and Controller","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:95923758dc801c113feff850aaf060082da957e50f03e59e4e12d5fcceba0124","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:08.21316+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:18","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:erica-a-austin","object_label":"Erica A. Austin","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Erica A. Austin: Senior Vice President, Human Resources","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:erica-a-austin","name":"Erica A. Austin"},"title":"Senior Vice President, Human Resources","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:1cc40753a07df0d340146b6a31866b2b6436ee5715f768d3aa4beff3d10c7c82","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:06.677265+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:19","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:jane-r-grimm","object_label":"Jane R. Grimm","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Jane R. Grimm: Vice President and Secretary","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:jane-r-grimm","name":"Jane R. Grimm"},"title":"Vice President and Secretary","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:75cb3bb815dcb881a2db52a4abae50a94ebebc6f4b8ec81e8d511c4e4590a107","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:07.664224+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:20","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:john-a-sunny","object_label":"John A. Sunny","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"John A. Sunny: Executive Vice President and Chief Information Officer","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:john-a-sunny","name":"John A. Sunny"},"title":"Executive Vice President and Chief Information Officer","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:f90faf3921477ad9d5d59decc6be70a296bd9d58922955a1e827a2c9fa7ec8ee","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:06.18203+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:21","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:kristin-b-mccoy","object_label":"Kristin B. McCoy","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Kristin B. McCoy: Executive Vice President, Tax","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:kristin-b-mccoy","name":"Kristin B. McCoy"},"title":"Executive Vice President, Tax","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e693815412a540221e8720f5bc68101ab32a65fe996d46a8a1aff85511e35a50","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:04.704466+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069:leadership_role:22","subject_id":"alpha:company:54c25110-d0e4-47ff-b0ce-8be2234e0069","predicate":"alpha:hasExecutiveRole","object_id":"alpha:person:michael-s-simmons","object_label":"Michael S. Simmons","object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Michael S. Simmons: Vice Chairman of the Board, President and Chief Executive Officer","claim_type":"leadership_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:leadership_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"leadership_role","human_label":"Leadership Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"kind":"executive_role","person":{"alpha_id":"alpha:person:michael-s-simmons","name":"Michael S. Simmons"},"title":"Vice Chairman of the Board, President and Chief Executive Officer","role_category":"executive","committee":null,"is_board_chair":false,"is_independent":null,"start_date":"2026-04-01","end_date":null},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:9fc073d121e7162bca753d4d8c5a0cc5d147538561f518d01914915832bbef7b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:04.20403+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.94,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-1:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce:ro-d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"}],"evidence":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e0781bf94b6d506bd5996d62ac13a6731f5d32d038e0ebae59c56e92c59edbce","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":"DEF 14A vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-09-02T02:01:36.766922+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:c74062ddb7d336f2c41ca00825a0ab87d07ddbe5205b64e270f2062994260d11","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:05.684214+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:9e14fccee8b3ea42c566650d6d1fcc28f3ff70bdb888eba2840af0a82ff882de","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:05.192448+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:a7444fd9db9c37a109511f14bb33d682f5fd0e208d7b1115b91c3036b181e715","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:08.683262+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:06065325ba53f45113611cf5857af2293fab41f32461df2f355cec98d5661277","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:07.160163+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:201350d719a3bbee0189836c6db54ae548748c8bc0304f5263231c7e77b53b97","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:09.120039+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:95923758dc801c113feff850aaf060082da957e50f03e59e4e12d5fcceba0124","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:08.21316+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:1cc40753a07df0d340146b6a31866b2b6436ee5715f768d3aa4beff3d10c7c82","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:06.677265+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:75cb3bb815dcb881a2db52a4abae50a94ebebc6f4b8ec81e8d511c4e4590a107","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:07.664224+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:f90faf3921477ad9d5d59decc6be70a296bd9d58922955a1e827a2c9fa7ec8ee","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:06.18203+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:e693815412a540221e8720f5bc68101ab32a65fe996d46a8a1aff85511e35a50","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:04.704466+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:9fc073d121e7162bca753d4d8c5a0cc5d147538561f518d01914915832bbef7b","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"VHI DEF 14A executive officers","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/59255/000005925526000012/vhl-20260521xdef14a.htm","source_date":"2026-04-01T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T09:51:04.20403+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"coverage_state":"PUBLISHED","quality":{"schema_version":"alpha-record-quality-v2","overall":0.857,"status":"strong","publication_readiness":"ready","dimensions":{"identity":1,"coverage":0.5,"freshness":1,"evidence_completeness":1,"source_authority":0.882,"cross_source_agreement":0.75,"temporal_completeness":1},"diagnostics":{"published_claims":22,"factual_claims":22,"claims_with_linked_evidence":22,"disputed_claims":0,"conflicts":0,"stale_claims":0,"stale_claim_ids":[],"temporal_claims":18,"temporal_claims_with_valid_from":18,"missing_coverage_sections":["governance","financials","workforce","ownership","ratings"],"missing_expected_claims":["headquarters","official_website","committee","financial_metric","governance_document","ownership","auditor","legal_matter","risk","ai_governance"]},"derivation":"deterministic_record_projection"},"publication":{"state":"PUBLISHED","published_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","observed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00","verified_at":"2026-10-19T14:44:33.16687+00:00"},"verification":{"schema_version":"alpha-verification-states-v1","state":"source_reported","identity_ownership":"unclaimed","assurance_level":null,"claim_state_counts":{"source_reported":22,"corroborated":0,"alpha_verified":0,"disputed":0,"superseded":0},"derivation":"claim_states+identity_ownership","summary":"Published claims are reported by public sources; none is Alpha verified. Profile ownership is unclaimed.","facets":[{"facet":"identity","state":"unclaimed"},{"facet":"evidence","state":"source_reported"},{"facet":"evaluation","state":"not_evaluated"},{"facet":"monitoring","state":null},{"facet":"authority","state":null},{"facet":"freshness","state":"current"}]},"rights":{"public_retrieval":"allowed","agent_retrieval":"allowed","redistribution":"not_granted","model_training":"not_granted","commercial_use":"not_specified","relationship_pathfinding":"not_granted","direct_contact":"not_granted"},"resource":{"uri":"alpha://company/valhi-inc-de/relationships","section":"relationships","href":"https://registry.alpha.ac/api/public/companies/valhi-inc-de?format=record&section=relationships","media_type":"application/json","availability":"contract"},"limitations":["Absence of a leadership role, committee, or disclosure is not evidence that it does not exist.","Only explicitly published canonical company identity and current confirmed public roles are included.","Absence of a board, committee, executive, listing, or claim is not evidence that it does not exist.","Public retrieval does not grant redistribution, model-training, direct-contact, or relationship-pathfinding rights.","This Company Profile is an identity and evidence record, not an Alpha rating."]}