{"schema_version":"alpha-governance-record-v2","alpha_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce","ontology_version":"alpha-governance-ontology-v1","as_of":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.995837+00:00","published_at":"2026-04-21T02:55:15.270549+00:00","section":"evidence","data":{"state":"PUBLISHED","evidence":[{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7cc56ccc01123c5d189f7f285498f092c4041d5b6c5f26bff2a475f361f8d5ed","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","title":"PNW DEF 14A director slate","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.34984+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:ai_ml_experience:1","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_role:5","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:committee_assignments:8","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:cybersecurity_experience:9","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:technology_background:10","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:ai_ml_experience:1","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_role:5","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:committee_assignments:8","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:cybersecurity_experience:9","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:technology_background:10"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:0f30ddf0b36988031ca1cbe060609c7298628839e2d73f5cc20543ed91377cee","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_proxy","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2026-04-03","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:13:00.489+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:role:1","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:role:1"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:3babe06d88ef988d9b547ef9d379094990309b4d7c98c5f44b5996170601b79c","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","title":"The Williams Companies, Inc. director board source","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_independence:2","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:3","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:4","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:committee_assignments:6","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_independence:2","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:3","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:4","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:committee_assignments:6"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:5610e7c9f2c46099bc2f3677771e766e48a26fab87db16bc6674b617c2315462","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","title":"WMB DEF 14A director slate","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-04-30T06:40:16.728952+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_role:5","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:committee_assignments:7","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_role:5","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:committee_assignments:7"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:601bc7ac3181d813fcf0eac19a10fae2d8fe7a35955479829338821b285998c8","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000076462225000035/pnw-20250401.htm","title":"Pinnacle West Capital Corporation director board source","identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2025-04-08T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_independence:2","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:3","stance":"supports"},{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:4","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_independence:2","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:3","alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:4"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:074e037334a372949d365da4a3f1a96c3e275bb0ab6027ddede6f6724847454d","aliases":[],"source_type":"sec_filing","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":"2016-01-01","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:role:2","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:role:2"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:9246c7a6468c07550ffa211b85d505b7a5cbf0602391eb72bf6d03bc45e21f8b","aliases":[],"source_type":"public_source","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:3","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:3"]},{"evidence_id":"alpha:projection-evidence:7b6ac70d9f122b3b939de4036220e1f717b608766273aa84d442dec8d0adbfd0","aliases":[],"source_type":"public_source","source_family":"sec","publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","title":null,"identifier":null,"locator":null,"source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"content_hash":null,"authority":{"policy_version":"alpha-source-authority-v1","tier":"authoritative","score":100,"source_family":"sec","reasons":["Matched sec source policy."]},"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"},"stance":[{"claim_id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:4","stance":"supports"}],"claim_ids":["alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:4"]}]},"claims":[{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:role:1","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:hasCurrentRole","object_id":"alpha:company:pinnacle-west-capital-corp","object_label":"Pinnacle West Capital","object_source_name_forms":["Pinnacle West Capital"],"value":"Independent Director at Pinnacle West Capital","claim_type":"professional_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:professional_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"professional_role","human_label":"Professional Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"role_category":"director"},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2021-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.293+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:0f30ddf0b36988031ca1cbe060609c7298628839e2d73f5cc20543ed91377cee","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":"2026-04-03","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:13:00.489+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-03","effective_from":"2021-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.293+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.85,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:role:2","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:hasCurrentRole","object_id":"alpha:company:williams-companies-inc","object_label":"Williams Companies","object_source_name_forms":["Williams Companies"],"value":"Director at Williams Companies","claim_type":"professional_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:professional_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"professional_role","human_label":"Professional Role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"role_category":"director"},"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2016-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.293+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:074e037334a372949d365da4a3f1a96c3e275bb0ab6027ddede6f6724847454d","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2016-01-01","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2016-01-01","effective_from":"2016-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.293+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:ai_ml_experience:1","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:ai_ml_experience","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"AI and ML experience: not identified in the cited filing","claim_type":"ai_ml_experience","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:ai_ml_experience","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"ai_ml_experience","human_label":"AI and ML experience","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":false,"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.448563+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7cc56ccc01123c5d189f7f285498f092c4041d5b6c5f26bff2a475f361f8d5ed","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"PNW DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.34984+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.448563+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.72,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_independence:2","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:board_independence","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Independent director","claim_type":"board_independence","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_independence","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_independence","human_label":"Board independence","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":true,"corroboration_count":2,"source_claim_count":2,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:40.400287+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:3babe06d88ef988d9b547ef9d379094990309b4d7c98c5f44b5996170601b79c","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"The Williams Companies, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:601bc7ac3181d813fcf0eac19a10fae2d8fe7a35955479829338821b285998c8","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Pinnacle West Capital Corporation director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000076462225000035/pnw-20250401.htm","source_date":"2025-04-08T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:40.400287+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:3","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:board_membership","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Serves on the board of Pinnacle West Capital Corporation","claim_type":"board_membership","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_membership","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_membership","human_label":"Board membership","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"name":"Pinnacle West Capital Corporation","ticker":"PNW"},"corroboration_count":3,"source_claim_count":4,"valid_from":"2021-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:40.400287+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:601bc7ac3181d813fcf0eac19a10fae2d8fe7a35955479829338821b285998c8","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Pinnacle West Capital Corporation director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000076462225000035/pnw-20250401.htm","source_date":"2025-04-08T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:9246c7a6468c07550ffa211b85d505b7a5cbf0602391eb72bf6d03bc45e21f8b","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:3babe06d88ef988d9b547ef9d379094990309b4d7c98c5f44b5996170601b79c","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"The Williams Companies, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2025-04-08T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2021-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:40.400287+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_membership:4","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:board_membership","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Serves on the board of The Williams Companies, Inc.","claim_type":"board_membership","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_membership","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_membership","human_label":"Board membership","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"name":"The Williams Companies, Inc.","ticker":"WMB"},"corroboration_count":3,"source_claim_count":4,"valid_from":"2016-01-01","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:40.400287+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:3babe06d88ef988d9b547ef9d379094990309b4d7c98c5f44b5996170601b79c","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"The Williams Companies, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:7b6ac70d9f122b3b939de4036220e1f717b608766273aa84d442dec8d0adbfd0","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:601bc7ac3181d813fcf0eac19a10fae2d8fe7a35955479829338821b285998c8","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Pinnacle West Capital Corporation director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000076462225000035/pnw-20250401.htm","source_date":"2025-04-08T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2016-01-01","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:40.400287+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:board_role:5","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:board_role","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Board role: Director","claim_type":"board_role","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:board_role","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"board_role","human_label":"Board role","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":{"title":"Director"},"corroboration_count":2,"source_claim_count":2,"valid_from":"2026-03-18","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-04-30T06:40:16.816816+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7cc56ccc01123c5d189f7f285498f092c4041d5b6c5f26bff2a475f361f8d5ed","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"PNW DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.34984+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:5610e7c9f2c46099bc2f3677771e766e48a26fab87db16bc6674b617c2315462","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"WMB DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-04-30T06:40:16.728952+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-03-18","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.415577+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"corroborated","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.92,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:committee_assignments:6","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:committee_assignments","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"No committee assignment disclosed in the cited filing","claim_type":"committee_assignments","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:committee_assignments","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"committee_assignments","human_label":"Committee assignments","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":[],"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:40.400287+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:3babe06d88ef988d9b547ef9d379094990309b4d7c98c5f44b5996170601b79c","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"The Williams Companies, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-03T01:56:40.400287+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.95,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:committee_assignments:7","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:committee_assignments","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Committee assignments: Compensation, Nominating/Governance","claim_type":"committee_assignments","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:committee_assignments","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"committee_assignments","human_label":"Committee assignments","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":["Compensation","Nominating/Governance"],"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-03-18","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-04-30T06:40:16.837909+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:5610e7c9f2c46099bc2f3677771e766e48a26fab87db16bc6674b617c2315462","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"WMB DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-04-30T06:40:16.728952+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-03-18","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-04-30T06:40:16.837909+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:committee_assignments:8","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:committee_assignments","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Committee assignments: Corporate Governance and Nominating, Human Resources, Nuclear and Operating","claim_type":"committee_assignments","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:committee_assignments","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"committee_assignments","human_label":"Committee assignments","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":["Corporate Governance and Nominating","Human Resources","Nuclear and Operating"],"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":"2026-04-03","valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.432446+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7cc56ccc01123c5d189f7f285498f092c4041d5b6c5f26bff2a475f361f8d5ed","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"PNW DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.34984+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":"2026-04-03","effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.432446+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.88,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:cybersecurity_experience:9","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:cybersecurity_experience","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Cybersecurity experience: not identified in the cited filing","claim_type":"cybersecurity_experience","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:cybersecurity_experience","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"cybersecurity_experience","human_label":"Cybersecurity experience","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":false,"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.485258+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7cc56ccc01123c5d189f7f285498f092c4041d5b6c5f26bff2a475f361f8d5ed","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"PNW DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.34984+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.485258+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.72,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"},{"id":"alpha:claim:person:william-h-spence:technology_background:10","subject_id":"alpha:person:william-h-spence","predicate":"alpha:technology_background","object_id":null,"object_label":null,"object_source_name_forms":[],"value":"Technology background: not identified in the cited filing","claim_type":"technology_background","predicate_id":"alpha:predicate:technology_background","predicate_version":1,"machine_key":"technology_background","human_label":"Technology background","governed_predicate":true,"machine_value":false,"corroboration_count":1,"source_claim_count":1,"valid_from":null,"valid_to":null,"recorded_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.465775+00:00","sources":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7cc56ccc01123c5d189f7f285498f092c4041d5b6c5f26bff2a475f361f8d5ed","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"PNW DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.34984+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","effective_from":null,"effective_until":null,"observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.465775+00:00","verified_at":null,"verification_state":"source_reported","legacy_verification_label":"verified/confirmed","review_state":"none","confidence":0.72,"assertion_type":"source_reported","evidence_state":"linked","publication_state":"PUBLISHED","record_version":"public-0:d751713988987e9331980363e24189ce"}],"evidence":[{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:7cc56ccc01123c5d189f7f285498f092c4041d5b6c5f26bff2a475f361f8d5ed","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"PNW DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":"2026-04-03T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.34984+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:0f30ddf0b36988031ca1cbe060609c7298628839e2d73f5cc20543ed91377cee","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_proxy","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":"2026-04-03","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:13:00.489+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:3babe06d88ef988d9b547ef9d379094990309b4d7c98c5f44b5996170601b79c","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"The Williams Companies, Inc. director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:5610e7c9f2c46099bc2f3677771e766e48a26fab87db16bc6674b617c2315462","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"WMB DEF 14A director slate","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2026-03-18T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-04-30T06:40:16.728952+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:601bc7ac3181d813fcf0eac19a10fae2d8fe7a35955479829338821b285998c8","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":"Pinnacle West Capital Corporation director board source","publisher":"SEC EDGAR","url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000076462225000035/pnw-20250401.htm","source_date":"2025-04-08T00:00:00+00:00","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:document:074e037334a372949d365da4a3f1a96c3e275bb0ab6027ddede6f6724847454d","identity_scope":"source_document_reference","source_type":"sec_filing","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":"2016-01-01","retrieved_at":"2026-05-03T01:47:44.446969+00:00","locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:9246c7a6468c07550ffa211b85d505b7a5cbf0602391eb72bf6d03bc45e21f8b","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/764622/000162828026023516/pnw-20260403.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}},{"id":"alpha:projection-evidence:7b6ac70d9f122b3b939de4036220e1f717b608766273aa84d442dec8d0adbfd0","identity_scope":"representation_reference","source_type":"public_source","title":null,"publisher":null,"url":"https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/107263/000119312526112643/wmb-20260317.htm","source_date":null,"retrieved_at":null,"locator":null,"use_rights":{"schema_version":"alpha-source-use-rights-v1","classification":"unknown","public_retrieval":"not_specified","agent_retrieval":"not_specified","redistribution":"not_granted","derived_use":"not_specified","model_training":"not_granted","retention":"not_specified","attribution_required":null,"license_id":null,"terms_url":null,"reviewed_at":null,"derivation":"fail_closed_unknown"}}],"coverage_state":"PUBLISHED","quality":{"schema_version":"alpha-record-quality-v2","overall":0.943,"status":"excellent","publication_readiness":"ready","dimensions":{"identity":1,"coverage":0.8,"freshness":1,"evidence_completeness":1,"source_authority":1,"cross_source_agreement":0.833,"temporal_completeness":1},"diagnostics":{"published_claims":12,"factual_claims":12,"claims_with_linked_evidence":12,"disputed_claims":0,"conflicts":0,"stale_claims":0,"stale_claim_ids":[],"temporal_claims":2,"temporal_claims_with_valid_from":2,"missing_coverage_sections":["ratings"],"missing_expected_claims":[]},"derivation":"deterministic_record_projection"},"publication":{"state":"PUBLISHED","published_at":"2026-04-21T02:55:15.270549+00:00","observed_at":"2026-10-16T21:21:42.712962+00:00","reviewed_at":"2026-05-16T04:19:49.293+00:00","verified_at":null},"verification":{"schema_version":"alpha-verification-states-v1","state":"corroborated","identity_ownership":"unclaimed","assurance_level":null,"claim_state_counts":{"source_reported":8,"corroborated":4,"alpha_verified":0,"disputed":0,"superseded":0},"derivation":"claim_states+identity_ownership","summary":"At least one published claim is corroborated by two or more public sources. Profile ownership is unclaimed.","facets":[{"facet":"identity","state":"unclaimed"},{"facet":"evidence","state":"corroborated"},{"facet":"evaluation","state":"not_evaluated"},{"facet":"monitoring","state":null},{"facet":"authority","state":null},{"facet":"freshness","state":"current"}]},"rights":{"public_retrieval":"allowed","agent_retrieval":"allowed","redistribution":"not_granted","model_training":"not_granted","commercial_use":"not_specified","relationship_pathfinding":"not_granted","direct_contact":"not_granted"},"resource":{"uri":"alpha://person/william-h-spence/evidence","section":"evidence","href":"https://registry.alpha.ac/api/public/profiles/william-h-spence?format=record&section=evidence","media_type":"application/json","availability":"contract"},"limitations":["Only permissioned public claims and evidence are included.","Absence of a claim is not evidence that the underlying fact is false.","Public retrieval does not grant model-training or redistribution rights.","Private relationships and Council activity are excluded."]}